Characters
Player characters and everyone they meet.
Player characters
NPCs
- 53V3N
- Alejandro Ortiz
- Alissa Denton
- Ana and Amelia Ortiz
- Anderson and Kathy
- Angela Confetti
- Angela Confetti and Ronald Pigeon
- Angels (Unsleeping City)
- Aquamarine
- Art devils
- Babe Ruth
- Band / crew / audience
- Barista
- Becky
- Benjamin Dupree
- Big man in back row
- Bilbry
- Bodega owner
- Bridge troll friend
- Buddy
- Building Inspector
- Bystander with the Forester
- Bystanders
- Bystanders on the run
- Carl Sagan
- Centifax
- Claude
- Clerk
- Cockrash
- Cockroach
- Cockroaches
- Conjured dog and spider
- Constellations
- Cop
- Cops
- Cosmo
- Counselor
- Dale Lee
- David
- Dead bystander
- Deep demonic voice
- Deli Owner
- Diane, Matt, Delia
- Dog (Unsleeping City)
- Domovoi
- Don Confetti
- Don Confetti and the pixies
- Dr. Lugash Primjitzki
- Dr. Simms
- Dragon (Unsleeping City)
- Dream moth
- Drunk Guy
- Dumpling Man
- Dupree St. Croix
- Eliza
- Em
- Emiko Matsui
- Emma Lazarus
- Emotional-support Jack Russell
- Entertainment reporter
- Epona Cirillo
- Esteban
- Esther Sinclair
- Esther's message
- Eustace
- Ewan
- Faerie actors at Glamour
- Fan 1 and Fan 2
- Fractured man
- Frank the Gargoyle
- Fred and Marty
- French man
- Gabriela Sinclair
- Girl in the fire
- Gray child
- Green and Red
- Greg Prickthorn
- Helen
- Heroes
- High Priestess Hib-Hob
- Hipster Bug
- Hipsters / bystanders
- Homeless people
- Hot dog vendor
- Inwood unicorn
- Isabella Infierno
- Jackson Wei
- Jessica Pigeon
- John Wilkes Booth
- Johnny
- Josefina Gatsby
- Juicy cockroach
- Kevin
- Kingston's cleaner
- Kingston's mother and family
- Kingston's mother and father, Winston and Victoria
- La Gran Gata
- Lady Titania and Seelie warriors
- Lazarus
- Lenny
- Leprechaun
- Liz Herrera
- Locals in the laundromat
- Lou Gehrig
- Lowell Masters
- Maitre d'
- Man
- Man at the bar
- Man in reflection
- Marble statue at a flying grand piano
- Maria
- Mario Bicicleta
- Mario, Anthony, Maria, Vincenzo, Adriano
- Marta (Unsleeping City)
- Maserati
- Melissa
- Mitch Conlan
- Moon woman
- Mrs. Claus
- Mutant Santa Clauses
- New York One reporter
- New Yorkers
- O'Neil, Dwyer, Burns, and Moses
- Ogre caterers
- Ogre doorman
- Orlando
- Orlando and Rovias
- Others in the lineup
- Ox
- Party Goer
- Patricia Sinclair
- Pedestrians
- Perry
- Perry LaFev
- Perry Pidgeon
- Pigeons
- Pill
- Pixie mobsters
- Pizza Rat
- Priapus
- Priya Danger
- Puck
- Randy
- Rat catcher
- Rats (Unsleeping City)
- Rebecca
- Receptionist at St. Owen's
- Reporter / firefighters
- Ricky's parents
- Robert
- Robert Moses
- Ronald Pigeon
- Ronald Pigeon's friends
- Ronaldo Manticaster
- Rourke Redcap
- Rovias
- Ruth Bader Ginsburg
- Santa Claus
- SantaCon attendee
- Sean (Unsleeping City)
- Seelie warriors / dancers
- Sofia's client
- Soppressata deli owner
- Spectral crooked cops
- Spiritual New Yorkers
- St. Peter
- Stage effects
- Stained Glass Saint
- Statue of Liberty
- Stephen Sondheim
- Suit Buddy
- Sully Sullenberger
- Suzette
- Talking trash cans
- Teacher
- The American Dream
- The announcer
- The band
- The Beetle
- The bugsters
- The colossal mutant Santa
- The Denizens
- The drummer
- The dryad
- The Johns
- The last rat
- The mobster
- The ogre
- The pale people
- The Rat King
- The train
- Three trolls
- Titania
- Trash Cans
- Troll (Unsleeping City)
- Twig Blight
- Twinkle and Pinkie
- Unicorn
- Vampire at the Wall Street door
- Vampires and their donors
- Victoria and Winston
- Victoria Brown
- Voice 1 / Voice 2
- Voices in Pete's head
- Wally Kugrich
- Wally's father
- Whispers in the dark
- Willy
- Willy, Emma Lazarus, Lazarus
- Winston Brown
- Woman in the Moon
- Yagdash
- Young Girl