Little Miss Muffet

Where the head of a giant spider would be, Brennan describes the torso of a young girl holding a small bowl with a spoon in it, and says Little Miss Muffet sits at the center of a web, not in a tuffet at all NA E6·00:21:17 NA E6·00:21:29 NA E6·00:21:34. A card names her Little Miss Muffet (she/her), Curds & Whey Enthusiast, from Tales of Old Mother Goose NA E6·00:21:36. Brennan says this is not a naturally-occurring fairy tale: a creature scrambled between stories, monstrous and corrupted NA E6·00:21:58. She calls the party "little darlings" and says something hiding in the dark has put her under the charm of a wicked spell NA E6·00:22:48.

In the sixth episode she fights the party from her web, kicking the web so they fall prone, and swinging a razor-sharp spoon at Ylfa NA E6·00:25:09 NA E6·00:46:59. Timothy writes "curds and whey" into his book as he casts Shatter, and the book accepts it NA E6·00:35:55. When Ylfa says they could be friends NA E6·01:07:16, she answers "Nobody wants to be friends with me." NA E6·01:07:19 Later she says to Ylfa "I'm having a really hard time hitting you." NA E6·01:15:30 She adds "We would be friends." NA E6·01:15:36 Pib inspects her spoon and finds it a magical weapon, and Brennan says it quite possibly relates to the plate they met earlier NA E6·01:13:17 NA E6·01:13:26.

Brennan describes Timothy's memory of a lonely, timid little girl who often ate alone on a hill with a cushion, and the spider carapace falls away and Brennan says it is Little Miss Muffet with a spider face, who throws curds and whey on Rosamund to heal her for one hit point NA E6·01:28:28 NA E6·01:30:06. She says "Oh, I'm not a spider anymore." NA E6·01:30:35 She says "I'm scared of spiders!" NA E6·01:30:59 Timothy writes the spider rhyme into his book, and the spider form vanishes into it NA E6·01:32:28 NA E6·01:32:31. She asks "Can I touch it?" NA E6·01:33:09 Timothy first says to wait, but Ylfa says to let her NA E6·01:33:38 NA E6·01:34:08. When she touches the book Brennan says an illustration appears of her running from a spider on a hill NA E6·01:34:31. She asks "Am I always supposed to be scared?" NA E6·01:35:29 She says "You guys saved me" and takes her hand off the golden door into the book NA E6·01:37:09. She says "I want to help you guys." NA E6·01:37:16

In the seventh episode Brennan says she has decided not to enter the door into Mother Goose's book and is the first person met in the Neverafter who chose to stay with the party NA E7·00:02:48. She says that as a big spider she put everyone in the village in cocoons, and that being scared of spiders is the number one thing anyone knows about her NA E7·00:03:34 NA E7·00:30:18. She travels hooded so that no one sees her face, and she says you can do your chores and still have fun NA E7·00:55:27 NA E7·00:56:28. She screams when she sees the Itsy Bitsy Spider NA E7·00:28:02. In The Lines Between Brennan lists her among the helpers who arrive with the party NA E8·00:04:45. In the seventeenth episode the illustration in Mother Goose's book shows her helping the Itsy Bitsy Spider up a rain cloud, their expressions now concerned NA E17·01:30:35 NA E17·01:30:57.